Starting with Vista/Srv08, local kernel debugging support has been locked down to require that the system was booted /DEBUG before-hand.

For me, this has been the source of great annoyance, as if something strange happens to a Vista/Srv08 box that requires peering into kernel mode (usually to get a stack trace), then one tends to hit a brick wall if the box wasn’t booted with /DEBUG. (The only supported option usually available would be manually bugcheck the box and hope that the crash dump, if the system was configured to write one, has useful data. This is, of course, not a particularly great option; especially as in the default configuration for dumps on Vista/Srv08, it’s likely that user mode memory won’t be captured.)

However, it turns out that there’s limited support in the operating system to capture some kernel mode data for debugging purposes, even if you haven’t booted /DEBUG. Specifically, kdbgctrl.exe (a tool shipping with the WinDbg distribution) supports the notion of capturing a “kernel triage dump”, which basically takes a miniature snapshot of a given process and its active user mode threads. To use this feature, you need to have SeDebugPrivilege (i.e. you need to be an administrative-equivalently-privileged user).

Unlike conventional local KD support, triage dump writing doesn’t give unrestricted access to kernel mode memory on a live system. Instead, it instructs the kernel to create a small dump file that contains a limited, pre-set amount of information (mostly, just the process and associated threads, and if possible, the stacks of said threads). As a result, you can’t use it for general kernel memory examination. However, it’s sometimes enough to do the trick if you just need to capture what the kernel mode side stack trace of a particular thread is.

To use this feature, you can invoke “kdbgctrl.exe -td pid dump-filename“, which takes a snapshot of the process identified by a pid, and writes it out to a dump file named by dump-filename. This support is very tersely documented if you invoke kdbgctrl.exe on the command line with no arguments:

Usage: kdbgctrl <options>
 <file> - Get a kernel triage dump
Now, the kernel’s support for writing out a triage dump isn’t by any means directly comparable to the power afforded by kd.exe -kl. As previously mentioned, the dump is extremely minimalistic, only containing information about a process object and its associated threads and the bare minimums allowing the debugger to function enough to pull this information from the dump. Just about all that you can reasonably expect to do with it is examine the stacks of the process that was captured, via the “!process -1 1f” command. (In addition, some extra information, such as the set of pending APCs attached to each thread, is also saved - enough to allow “!apc thread” to function.) Sometimes, however, it’s just enough to be able to figure out what something is blocking on kernel mode side (especially when troubleshooting deadlocks), and the triage dump functionality can aid with that.

However, there are some limitations with triage dumps, even above the relatively terse amount of data they convey. The triage dump support needs to be careful not to crash the system when writing out the dump, so all of this information is captured within the normal confines of safe kernel mode operation. In particular, this means that the triage dump writing logic doesn’t just blithely walk the thread or process lists like kd -kl would, or perform other potentially unsafe operations.

Instead, the triage dump creation process operates with the cooperation of all threads involved. This is immediately apparent when taking a look at the thread stacks captured in a triage dump:

BugCheck 69696969, {0, 0, 0, 0}

Probably caused by : ntkrnlmp.exe ( nt!IopKernSnapAPCMiniDump+55 )

Followup: MachineOwner

2: kd> k
Call Site
(Note that the system doesn’t actually bugcheck as a result of creating a triage dump. Kernel dumps implicitly need a bug check parameters record, however, so one is synthesized for the dump file.)

As is immediately obvious from the call stack, thread stack collection in triage dumps operates (in Vista/Srv08) by tripping a kernel APC on the target thread, which then (as it’s in-thread-context) safely collects data about that thread’s stack.

This, of course, presents a limitation: If a thread is sufficiently wedged such that it can’t run kernel APCs, then a triage dump won’t be able to capture full information about that thread. However, for some classes of scenarios where simply capturing a kernel mode stack is sufficient, triage dumps can sometimes fill in the gap in conjuction with user mode debugging, even if the system wasn’t booted with /DEBUG.